Variable Universal Life Insurance (VUL)

Posted on by user

Variable universal life (VUL) insurance combines lifelong death benefit protection with a cash-value account that you can invest in subaccounts similar to mutual funds. It offers flexible premiums and tax-deferred growth, but places investment risk—and many fees—on the policyholder.

How VUL works

  • VUL is a permanent life insurance policy with two parts: a death benefit and a cash-value account.
  • Premiums cover insurance costs first; any remaining premium is invested in subaccounts you choose.
  • You can change premium amounts (within policy limits) and shift investments among available subaccounts.
  • Cash value grows tax-deferred and can be accessed via withdrawals or policy loans. Poor investment performance can reduce cash value and may require higher premiums to keep the policy in force.

Investment options and administration

  • Subaccounts function like a family of mutual funds (stocks, bonds, money market, sometimes ETFs or a fixed-interest option).
  • Subaccount performance determines cash-value growth—there is no guaranteed return.
  • Because subaccounts are securities, agents selling VUL must be properly licensed and registered.
  • Policies may limit free transfers among subaccounts and charge fees for excess transfers.

Fees and costs

  • Typical fees include:
  • Mortality and expense charges for the insurance component
  • Administrative fees
  • Subaccount management (investment) fees (often ~0.5%–2%)
  • Possible surrender charges for early cancellation (commonly assessed for the first 10–15 years)
  • Fees and the cost of insurance reduce overall returns and can make VUL less competitive than investing outside a policy.

Risks and downsides

  • Investment risk is borne by the policyholder—poor returns can deplete cash value.
  • If cash value is insufficient to cover insurance costs, you must increase premiums or risk policy lapse.
  • Complexity: managing investments, monitoring fees, and understanding policy mechanics requires attention and financial sophistication.
  • Surrender charges can make early exit costly.

Potential advantages

  • Flexibility to adjust premium payments (within policy rules).
  • Opportunity for higher cash-value growth compared with other permanent policies when markets perform well.
  • Tax-deferred accumulation of investment gains inside the policy.
  • Access to cash value via loans or withdrawals while alive.

Who might consider VUL

VUL can suit individuals who:
* Want permanent life insurance and are comfortable with investment risk.
* Prefer hands-on control of policy investments.
* Have already maximized other tax-advantaged retirement accounts and seek additional tax-deferred growth.
It is generally not ideal for those seeking guaranteed, low-risk cash-value growth or for buyers who prefer simple, low-cost life insurance.

Alternatives (brief comparisons)

  • Variable life: Similar investment options but typically fixed premiums; may offer a guaranteed minimum death benefit.
  • Universal life: Adjustable premiums with cash value tied to interest rates; often includes a guaranteed minimum growth rate.
  • Whole life: Fixed premiums, guaranteed death benefit, and guaranteed cash-value growth—lower risk, lower upside.
  • Term life: Temporary coverage, no cash value, and much lower premiums—use savings to invest separately if desired.

Quick FAQs

Q: What does VUL stand for?
A: Variable universal life.

Q: Is VUL a good investment?
A: VUL can boost returns during strong market performance, but fees and insurance costs typically make it less efficient than investing directly through taxable or tax-advantaged brokerage accounts. It’s primarily an insurance product with an investment feature.

Q: What can VUL policies invest in?
A: Common options include subaccounts invested in stocks, bonds, money market funds, mutual funds, ETFs, and sometimes a fixed-interest option.

Bottom line

VUL offers flexible permanent life insurance combined with investment choice and tax-deferred growth. It can deliver higher cash-value growth when markets perform well, but it carries significant investment risk, complexity, and fees. Compare VUL carefully with other life insurance types and standalone investment strategies before deciding.